The Juiciest Meat You’ll Ever Eat Has Lost Its Juice

A slow braise draws water out of the meat and replaces it with gelatin. That’s why a humble beef shin can outdo a fillet, for far less money.

Hours in, the lid comes off and the pot gives back everything you were patient enough to give it.

In college at Virginia Tech, in Blacksburg, I cooked tandoori chicken and Indian chicken often, and it came out excellent. I marinated the chicken, browned it hard in a pan with the spices, then slid it into an oven turned down very low and left it alone to perfume the kitchen.

Push that patience further and you get beef shin. Lift the lid after three hours and the kitchen exhales. Steam rolls out, heavy with onion and cumin, the garlic gone sweet. The shin has given up. A spoon parts the meat into dark, glossy ribbons, and the sauce clings to each one like velvet.

That meat is drier than when it went in. America’s Test Kitchen weighed braised meat before and after cooking: it lost an average of 12.5 percent of its weight while the liquid in the pot grew. Braising takes moisture out of meat. And still, every forkful tastes juicier than a steak.

So why does it taste so juicy?

Blame the muscle. A shin carries a cow’s weight all day, and a cheek chews all day. The harder a muscle works, the more collagen binds its fibres into tight bundles. A raw shin fights back like old rope.

Give it time and gentle heat, and the rope unravels. That tissue melts into gelatin, which coats every strand of meat in silk and helps it hold on to water. Your tongue reads that silk as juice. It’s a quiet, delicious con, and the cook is in on it.

Heat matters too. Cook’s Illustrated tests, as reported by The Daily Meal, found that meat roasted hot lost 25 percent of its moisture, against 9.25 percent at low heat. A hot pan fights a tough cut, and the cut wins. Low heat makes peace. That low oven in Blacksburg made peace every time.

What does time do to flavor?

Brown the meat hard first. Listen for the hiss and wait until it turns the color of mahogany. Season it boldly, then add whatever you love: bay, cinnamon, chilli, ginger, a fistful of garlic. Pour in the liquid, cover the pot and walk away.

Over the hours, something happens that a hurried cook never tastes. The spices stop announcing themselves one by one. Garlic, smoke, fat and beef melt into a single deep voice, close to bewitching. The next day it’s better still, because the meat reabsorbs some of the liquid as it cools.

Why do the cheap cuts win?

A fillet is prized for being tender already, so a long cook has nothing to improve and only dries it out. Lean filet mignon is almost guaranteed to come out bone-dry in a slow cooker.

The unfashionable cuts are the opposite: beef shin, beef cheeks, lamb breast, oxtail, once a cheap, throwaway cut. A patient pot turns each one into something richer and softer than it has any right to be, and in my book, better than most steaks. Better flavor and a gentler bite, for a smaller bill. For a family stretching a budget, that turns an ordinary grocery run into a feast.

It’s also a lost art. Restaurants rarely have the hours for it. Home cooks do, on a slow Saturday.

Is there such a thing as too slow?

Yes. Chef and author J. Kenji López-Alt, as reported by The Daily Meal, found that beef stewed five hours lost about as much moisture as beef stewed three, yet felt drier, because the gelatin was gone. Cut the beef into large chunks, hold the pot at a gentle simmer, and start checking at three hours. When a fork slides in without a fight, stop.

Can fish be slow-cooked too?

It can. Salmon is delicate and sulks under hard heat, pushing out a white protein called albumin, a sign that moisture has escaped. America’s Test Kitchen drops its oven to 275 degrees for the job. Go gently, and the flesh stays moist and slides apart in pink silk.

Get Aquib Ahmed’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Remember me for faster sign in

Then there’s hilsa, the “king of fish” across South Asia, magnificent in flavor and a thicket of fine bones. Plenty of people give up on it. The Daily Star, a Bangladeshi newspaper, runs a pressure-cooker recipe it titles boneless ilish: ten minutes on high heat, then an hour and a half on low. One home cook who tried a similar method found the bones softened to something like canned sardines. A pressure cooker is a hotter, faster cousin of the slow pot, but it keeps faith with the same rule. Give the stubborn part time and it surrenders.

Start this weekend

Pick one tough cut. Brown it hard, season it boldly, add liquid, cover, lower the flame and walk away. Read a book. Let the house fill with the smell of something that cannot be rushed.

Patience is a flavor.

Sources

1. America’s Test Kitchen, “The Truth About Braising”: https://www.americastestkitchen.com/cooksillustrated/how_tos/6365-the-truth-about-braising
2. Ricardo, “How to Perfect the Art of Braising”: https://ricardocuisine.com/en/articles/food-chemistry/643-how-to-perfect-the-art-of-braising
3. The Daily Meal, “The Science Behind Why Your Stew Meat Is Turning Out Dry” (source for the Cook’s Illustrated moisture figures and the J. Kenji López-Alt finding): https://www.thedailymeal.com/1381081/how-prevent-dry-meat-stew/
4. CKBK, “Juiciness”: https://app.ckbk.com/section/prof90208c16s004ss002sss004/juiciness
5. Food Republic, “Never Put Expensive Meats In Your Slow Cooker”: https://www.foodrepublic.com/2105452/avoid-expensive-meats-slow-cooker/
6. Tasting Table, “The Absolute Best Cuts Of Beef To Slow Cook”: https://www.tastingtable.com/876242/the-absolute-best-cuts-of-beef-to-slow-cook/
7. Gourmet Traveller, beef cheeks: https://www.gourmettraveller.com.au/?p=2051
8. Carnivore Society, “Stews & Braises: The Best Meat Cuts for Ultimate Flavor”: https://www.carnivoresociety.com.au/blogs/resources/best-meat-cuts-stews-braises
9. America’s Test Kitchen, “How to Roast Salmon Gently for the Silkiest Texture”: https://www.americastestkitchen.com/articles/how-to-roast-salmon-gently-for-the-silkiest-texture
10. Sitka Seafood Market, “What is That White Stuff on My Salmon?”: https://sitkaseafoodmarket.com/blogs/culinary/from-the-test-kitchen/what-is-that-white-stuff-on-my-salmon
11. Remitly, “Hilsa Fish in Bengali Culture”: https://www.remitly.com/blog/lifestyle-culture/nationaldishes-hilsa-fish-guide-bangladesh-dish/
12. The Daily Star, “5 delicious ilish recipes you must try”: https://www.thedailystar.net/life-living/food-recipes/news/5-delicious-ilish-recipes-you-must-try-3123126
13. Chumkie’s Kitchen, “Pressure-Cooked Doi Ilish”: https://chumkieskitchen.blogspot.com/2018/05/pressure-cooked-doi-ilish.html
14. The Kitchn, “What Exactly Is Braising?” (background): https://www.thekitchn.com/what-is-braising-23614335