The Legend of George Washington’s Conversion
Every few years an old story finds new life.
It is said that George Washington, as he lay dying at Mount Vernon in December 1799, quietly entered the Catholic Church. According to the legend, a Catholic priest was summoned, the nation’s first president made his confession, received the sacraments, and departed this life as a Catholic.
While an intriguing story, it is also one that historians have never been able to substantiate.
Washington’s final illness was witnessed by family members, physicians, servants, and close friends. Their recollections are unusually detailed, yet none mentions the arrival of a Catholic priest. The version most often repeated identifies the Jesuit Leonard Neale, later Archbishop of Baltimore, as the priest who supposedly received Washington into the Church. The difficulty is that this account surfaces decades after Washington’s death, not in the testimony of those who stood at his bedside.
For some readers, that may seem like the end of the matter.
But perhaps it is the beginning.
The persistence of this legend tells us something — not so much about George Washington as about American Catholics.
For much of our nation’s history, Catholics occupied an uncertain place in public life. Their loyalty was questioned. Their motives were misunderstood. Churches and convents were attacked. Political movements warned that Catholics could never be fully American because their first allegiance belonged elsewhere.
Against that backdrop, it is not difficult to understand why so many Catholics cherished the thought that the Father of His Country had, in the end, embraced the faith they loved.
Get James Day’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Perhaps the legend endured because Catholics were never really asking whether George Washington belonged to the Church.
They were asking whether the Church belonged in America.
History, however, points us toward something better than the legend.
When Washington assumed command of the Continental Army, anti-Catholic prejudice remained deeply rooted in many of the colonies. One of the more notorious customs inherited from England was “Pope Night,” an annual celebration in which crowds mocked the Holy Father with bonfires, effigies, and drunken revelry.
Washington prohibited it.
The decision was undoubtedly practical: the American cause depended upon the friendship of Catholic France, and insulting Catholics while seeking French support made little sense. Yet practical considerations do not diminish the significance of the moment. Another commander might have tolerated the custom. But it was that man, George Washington, who ended it.
His regard for Catholics continued after independence. When plans were made to appoint the first Catholic bishop in the United States, Washington recognized that the federal government possessed no authority over ecclesiastical appointments. It was a simple principle, yet a remarkable one in an age when governments often claimed such authority. He attended Catholic Mass on occasion, corresponded cordially with Bishop John Carroll, and in 1790 replied warmly to an address from American Catholics led by Carroll and signed by Charles Carroll of Carrollton, the only Catholic signer of the Declaration of Independence. Thanking them for their patriotism, Washington expressed his confidence that they would continue to demonstrate their fidelity to the new republic.
All this while anti-Catholic prejudice remained commonplace in the land Washington had sacrificed to free. The man some wished to make king was already presiding over common ground. Such quiet statesmanship would prove more consequential than any legendary deathbed conversion.
Washington helped establish a republic in which Catholics would build parishes and schools, hospitals and universities, charities and neighborhoods. They would serve as soldiers, judges, teachers, laborers, business owners, religious sisters, priests, missionaries, and public servants. They would help shape the nation even as the nation shaped them.
And so the real story is not that George Washington became Catholic, but that American Catholics became, without contradiction, fully Catholic and fully American.
Looking back over two and a half centuries, that is no small inheritance.
