Member-only story
A Roofer Says Insurance Will Buy You a New Roof. What Could Go Wrong?
After a storm, “Let insurance pay for it” can sound almost risk-free. It isn’t always.
This story was written with AI assistance under my editorial direction and was reviewed and fact-checked before publication.
A major storm passes through the neighborhood.
A few days later, roofing trucks begin appearing.
Then someone knocks on the door.
They offer a free inspection.
They climb onto the roof.
A few minutes later, they come down with good news:
“You have storm damage. Insurance should pay for a new roof.”
For a homeowner, that can sound almost perfect.
The roof may be getting older anyway.
The contractor says there was hail.
You have been paying homeowners insurance for years.
So why not file the claim?
And if the insurance company says no, what have you really lost?
That last question is where things become more complicated.
Because sometimes a homeowner starts this process expecting:
