Conversations with Moon: The Breath Hacker Edition
A second, unpublished sitting with Moon and Abhinav, in which nobody asks permission before feeling something
Off the record. Off the internet. Strictly between us.
The same drawing room, several nights later. The books have multiplied. ABHINAV is sitting cross legged on the floor, eyes closed, doing something with his nostrils that he insists is ancient and is, in fact, an app. MOON is watching him the way one watches a house slowly catching fire, with concern, and a little bit of enjoyment.
ACT I. REUNION, WITH COMPLICATIONS
MOON. You are doing the nostril thing again.
ABHINAV. It is called box breathing. Four counts in, four counts hold, four counts out, four counts hold. Navy SEALs use it.
MOON. You have never held a weapon heavier than a wine list.
ABHINAV. The breath does not know that. The breath just wants a system.
MOON. Last time we spoke, you were explaining chip supply chains and I was explaining why forests do not send thank you cards. Now you are auditioning for a monastery.
ABHINAV. A man contains multitudes. Also a man got a smart ring for his birthday and it has opinions about his sleep.
MOON. Did the courtroom of species teach you nothing. Did the plumbing race of artificial intelligence teach you nothing. You are still out here outsourcing your peace to a subscription.
ABHINAV. At least my subscription does not lie to shareholders.
MOON. Low blow. Accurate, but low.
ACT II. LOVE AS A FOREIGN POLICY
MOON. New question. One nobody has had the nerve to ask us directly. Is love a negotiation or a surrender.
ABHINAV. Depends who drafted the term sheet.
MOON. Be serious for one breath. Preferably not a boxed one.
ABHINAV. Fine. I think love starts as diplomacy. Two nations with their own currencies trying to agree on an exchange rate. Then, if you are lucky, it stops being diplomacy and starts being one country.
MOON. That is disgustingly romantic for a man who negotiates supply chains for fun.
ABHINAV. I contain layers. Like an onion, or a very well structured merger.
MOON. And what happens when the negotiation fails.
ABHINAV. Sanctions. Silence. A slow withdrawal of ambassadors, which is a poetic way of saying he stopped replying to her texts.
MOON. You say that like you have been on both sides of that border.
ABHINAV. I have been the ambassador who left and the country left behind. It is character building. Terrible for the economy.
MOON. Funny, I always thought heartbreak was the one treaty nobody actually signs. It just gets imposed on you.
ABHINAV. By whom.
MOON. By whoever loved you less carefully than you loved them. There is no tribunal for that. Only 3am and a phone you should not be holding.
• • •
ACT III. THE BREATH HACKER’S CONFESSION
MOON. Let us stay with your nostrils for a moment. Explain this lens of yours. The breath hacker lens, as you keep calling it, like it is a patented technology.
ABHINAV. It is simple. Every big feeling is just breath mismanagement wearing a costume. Anxiety is breath held too long out of fear. Rage is breath forced out too fast out of pride. Grief is breath that forgot how to finish its own sentence.
MOON. And love.
ABHINAV. Love is the only feeling where you actually forget to breathe on purpose, and enjoy it.
MOON. That is almost beautiful. I am furious about how almost it is.
ABHINAV. Thank you. I workshopped it during a cold plunge.
MOON. Of course you did. Tell me honestly, does standing in freezing water actually fix anything, or is it just very photogenic suffering.
ABHINAV. Both. That is the elite wellness business model in one sentence. Sell people a hard, cold, uncomfortable ritual and let them mistake the discomfort for growth.
Get Abhinav Jain’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
MOON. So the breath hacker admits the whole temple is a stage set.
ABHINAV. The breath hacker admits the temple works anyway, which is the annoying part. I still feel calmer. I just also feel slightly ridiculous, which might be the actual enlightenment.
MOON. You realise this is just meditation with better marketing and a subscription fee.
ABHINAV. Everything good eventually gets a subscription fee. Even you would charge for this conversation if you were less proud.
MOON. I would charge triple and you would still show up.
• • •
ACT IV. THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE EVERYTHING, AND NOBODY
ABHINAV. New exclusive question then, since you are collecting them. Why are the most successful people in every room usually the loneliest ones in it.
MOON. Because success is very good at attracting people who want something from you, and very bad at attracting people who simply want you.
ABHINAV. That is bleak.
MOON. That is Tuesday, for most of the people we know. They build the empire, acquire the house with the ocean view, hire the chef, and then eat dinner alone scrolling through four hundred contacts, unable to find one person to call who is not also an invoice.
ABHINAV. So what is the fix. More box breathing.
MOON. The fix is terrifying and unfashionable. It is choosing, on purpose, to be known by someone who cannot invoice you for it. No leverage, no networking angle, just two people agreeing to witness each other on a bad day.
ABHINAV. You are describing friendship like it is a hostile takeover nobody wants to attempt anymore.
MOON. Because it is the only merger left where you cannot buy your way to a majority stake. You either show up broke and honest, or you do not get in the room.
ABHINAV. And ambition. Where does that fit, since we are diagnosing everyone tonight.
MOON. Ambition is the lover who never asks if you are tired. It never checks your temperature, never notices the dark circles, simply asks what is next, at 2am, while you are still in yesterday’s clothes.
ABHINAV. You say that with the affection of someone still very much in that relationship.
MOON. We are all still in that relationship, darling. Some of us have simply learned to ask ambition to sleep in the other room occasionally.
• • •
ACT V. THE PART NEITHER OF US REHEARSED
ABHINAV. Can I ask you something I have never actually asked you.
MOON. You are asking permission. That alone tells me it is dangerous.
ABHINAV. Why do you always turn everything, love, grief, empire, chip wars, into a joke first.
MOON. Because the joke arrives faster than the honesty and gets there before I can talk myself out of feeling anything.
ABHINAV. That is the most sincere sentence you have said all night.
MOON. Do not tell anyone. My whole brand depends on people thinking I feel nothing and know everything.
ABHINAV. For what it is worth, I think the sarcasm is the least interesting thing about you.
MOON. Careful. Compliments delivered without irony make me nervous. It is like watching you breathe without counting.
ABHINAV. Maybe tonight I will not count.
MOON. Then hold my hand instead of your breath, and let us see which one actually calms you down.
• • •
Two people who have already argued about ecosystems, superpowers and spreadsheets discover, somewhat against their will, that the hardest negotiation was never out there in the forest, the chip fabs or the boardroom. It was the one happening between a held breath and an honest word.
The breath hacker’s lens turns out to be less about oxygen and more about permission, permission to feel something before performing it, and permission to laugh at yourself while doing it. Wit, it turns out, was never armour against love. It was simply love, arriving early and overdressed.
Every system you build to control a feeling, box breathing, cold plunges, sarcasm, ambition, success, is only ever borrowed time. The feeling will eventually ask to be let in without a script. The elite version of courage is not another hack. It is simply exhaling in front of someone and trusting them to still be there when you do.
End of Conversation, For Now
