We have recently transitioned from Installshield to Advanced Installer and are generally quite pleased with the new software. However, the elephant stomping around the room is the patch install technology which seems to leave us with a real problem.
Our software is a typical application where we have a functional point release (e.g 8.1, 8.2, 8.3,...) and several interim maintenance or service pack releases (8.1 SP1, 8.1 SP2, etc..). Our assumption is that each point release is a full install and forms a new baseline for the subsequent service pack patch installs. Our options here seem to be :
1) Create a patch against the base copy for each service pack release.
2) Create a separate installer with only the modified directories at each service pack release.
It seems we cannot use patch installers with watch directories as they use reference id's rather than filenames. Attempting to manually check each file in the directories on each patch build is time-consuming, dangerous and bound to go wrong.
On the other hand, If we roll our own second installer it looks as though we will have problems with repairs/un-installs and also with product grouping, versioning and build numbers.
I'm sure we are missing something here. Could somebody please advise :
- If I build a Service Pack 5 patch (8.0 SP5) by diffing against our baseline release (8.0 SP0) will that install service all users with interim service pack releases (8.0 SP0 users, SP1 users, SP2 users, SP3 users, SP4 users) ? Logically, it could as the file changes will be incremental over SP releases. If not, am I right in saying that I would need to build and maintain 10 different patch installs to migrate users from 8.0 SPx up to 8.0 SP5 ?
- How can I create a patch install with watched directories ? If I can't, some way to manage this that doesn't involve manual comparison of thousands of files ?
- How is everyone else doing this ? Surely this is a standard requirement in application software.
- Is there a wiki or a procedure I can reference ?
Many thanks.
Iain.
FOLLOW US
Get the latest news in Application Packaging