Scenerio Sense Check - Advanced Installer Community
scruffyduck
Posts: 2
Joined: Thu Jan 09, 2014 6:36 pm

Scenerio Sense Check

First let me start with an apology - that is I am probably asking something that has been answered before and I know how annoying that can be. However in my defense I have a set of specific requirements and while I can guess what could work and what version I probably need I would appreciate confirmation. I am pretty sure that I am going to need to spend some money with you in order to get what I need and that is not a trivial sum in my situation.

I currently use a competing product which I hate with a vengeance! I find it obtuse, picky and very hard to use - no I am not going to say what it is.

Here is my scenario. I have several applications but one is by far larger and more complex than the others. I generally have two versions in play - production and beta. I would like to install them side by side (which I understand I can do with Advanced Installer) Both get updated regularly - the overall package is large and I do not want to release a full installer for each update. I do have an online updater which delivers updates to the production version by checking on-line. However some of my users do not like it - do not have my app on an internet connected computer. I therefore need to deliver an update package outside of the App - I think to do this I am going to need the Pro version(hence the dosh). So I want to be able to maintain two side by side versions. I want to be able to provide online updates to each; I want to be able to provide user downloaded and executed updates with a few files for each and I want to have full installers for major versions. At some point the beta version will become the production and need to update the current production and I would then create a new beta installer. Can AI provide in App Updates?

Finally I don't like scripting and I am not that great with complexity!

If you have gotten this far many thanks for reading. I would appreciate your feedback


Jon
ScruffyDuck Software
Microsoft MVP
Bogdan
Posts: 2796
Joined: Tue Jul 07, 2009 7:34 am
Contact: Website

Re: Scenerio Sense Check

Hi Jon,

Thank you for trying out Advanced Installer.

First of all, for MVPs we have a special licenses plan, just mail me at bogdan at advancedinstaller dot com, include a link to your MVP profile, and I can give you more details.

Now, regarding your packages. First you need to take of migrating your installer(s) to Advanced Installer. I assume the old installer was MSI based too, so to make sure you correctly
migrate to Advanced Installer you should copy the upgrade code from the old projects and use it in the AI project. Also, please make sure that you have the same installation type set
in the new AI package, i.e. per-user or per-machine, just as you had in the old package.

Now, regarding automatic updates, this will be a long for you :). Handling updates might seem easy in the beginning, but things can get complicated, especially when you had two versions
of the application, like production and beta. Before you start working on setting up the updates support I would recommend reading a few of the existent forum threads, like the next one:
- updates for different languages and channels

Advanced Installer has an updater tool that is capable of deploying new versions. These new version can either be a a full package, i.e. MSI or EXE, or just patches, i.e. MSP packages.
The updater can be called by the users manually from a shortcut, using a scheduled task or directly from your own application.

Also, for side by side installs you need to make sure your application is designed to support this. Here I am referring at application resource isolation, i.e. your application needs to have
the files and registry written in locations that are different, so they don't get overwritten. If your application installs any Windows services you must make sure the services have unique name.
The easiest way to handle this is to include the product version in both the installation paths and registry keys, but also in the service names, or at least a keyword, like "Beta", which maybe
would make more sense in your case since you actually will have users just having either just the production version or both the production an beta versions, but not multiple production versions
side by side.

Regards,
Bogdan
Bogdan Mitrache - Advanced Installer Team
Follow us: Twitter - Facebook - YouTube
scruffyduck
Posts: 2
Joined: Thu Jan 09, 2014 6:36 pm

Re: Scenerio Sense Check

Hi Bogdan

Thanks very much for your reply. I have emailed you as suggested. I do not think my current installer is MSI based. In the past major new releases have been installed side by side with the current production version. Good to keep things clean but migrating user data always causes some issues so we have had an installer to upgrade existing versions in the past.

I will check the links you give. I have only the two installations at any one time. They have different product names and are independent in the registry etc. The only link is that at a certain time the production product will be updated with the beta. I just need to get everything onto one installer after the next major release. Users should not have multiple production versions side by side but some seem to try and keep old ones!

Return to “Common Problems”